Daily Archives: July 8, 2009

1 post

First Briefs for NRA/SAF v. Chicago

California Attorney General and former Presidential Candidate Edmund “Jerry” Brown has submitted an Amicus Curiae brief (pdf), asking the Supreme Court to hear the joint NRA and SAF suits against Chicago.  At first, it seems surprising and perhaps a bit heartening, but don’t worry, Brown’s got an agenda here.

It opens with the pronoucement:

(…) unlike many states, California has no state constitutional counterpart to the Second Amendment. Unless the protections of the Second Amendment extend to citizens living in the States as well as to those living in federal enclaves, California citizens could be deprived of the constitutional right to possess handguns in their homes as affirmed in District of Columbia v. Heller.

He points out that the Heller ruling failed, “to establish a standard of review applicable to asserted Second-Amendment infringements,” which is correct.  He also concurs with Halbrook and Gura that the current schism between the 9th Circuit and other circuit courts on the matter of incorporation can only be settled by the Supreme Court.